Shallot farming in Indonesia has significant risks, primarily due to production variability and price instability. These risks deter farmers from adopting strategies involving higher risk tolerance levels. Risk aversion varies across individuals, leading to differences in decision-making processes. The study examines income risk levels in shallot farming. It explores farmers' behaviors in response to these risks in two distinct regions: the highlands of Karanganyar Regency, Central Java, and the lowlands of Bantul Regency, Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta. A total of 200 shallot farmers were randomly selected for structured interviews to assess their risk behavior and the factors influencing it. The analysis reveals that shallot farming entails a high degree of income risk, and the highland areas exhibit a greater coefficient of variation (0.574) compared to the lowlands (0.544). Approximately 65% of highland farmers and 80% of lowland farmers were observed to be risk-averse concerning their shallot farming activities. Key factors influencing risk behavior include land size, household size, farming experience, age, frequency of crop failure, education, income, and farming location. Notably, farming experience, education, household size, and income positively impact risk behavior, increasing farmers' likelihood of adopting risk-taking strategies. The primary source of income risk was production variability, exacerbated by staggered planting schedules. This study highlights the importance of synchronizing planting schedules and strengthening farmer group networks to improve planning, marketing, input procurement, and knowledge exchange. The findings also provide a foundation for policymakers to design regulations that optimize planting times and mitigate income risks in shallot farming.